Kerbin Herald
KerbNet Navigatorv3.14 · Kerbin
🔒kerbin://internet/herald/stories/belugax-and-meteor
HESTIA● KSS
⚜ Long read|ANALYSIS
← All stories

BelugaX failed three times. BelugaX-4 flew. The program launched a crew on the fourth attempt.

HANDOFF, CASCADE, and AEGIS failed in sequence - stage separation, engine cascade, heatshield decouple. METEOR, the fourth flight, succeeded. HESTIA crew launched on its back.

The BelugaX programme had three failures before it had one success. HANDOFF failed at stage separation. CASCADE failed in an engine cascade - multiple engines, sequential failure, vehicle loss. AEGIS failed at heatshield decouple - the heatshield separated from the vehicle at a point in flight where heatshield attachment is the entire job. Three vehicles. Three distinct failure modes. Zero crew on any of them, because all three were uncrewed.

METEOR - BelugaX-4 - flew clean. Full mission profile. Ocean recovery. The vehicle performed within parameters across every phase. NASA then approved crew launch on the BelugaX platform. TENDING and MUSTER - the two HESTIA crew launches - both used the BelugaX-derived OTS system. Both succeeded.

The Herald's assessment: the program accepted a vehicle with a 25% success rate for crewed operations after one clean flight. This is either confidence in corrective engineering or a schedule pressure the program has not disclosed. We have asked. We have received a PDF that contains the words "extensive recertification" and "corrective action plan" and very little else. We will continue to press.